Art and Music
A wonderful evening was had by all at Gliffaes Country House Hotel, Crickhowell, Powys joining Lucy Corbett to launch the new Welsh Academy of Art. The WAA provides residents and visitors with the unique opportunity to learn the classical methods of drawing and painting. This school is open to anyone with a passion to learn and one of its kind in Wales. Enjoyment in the practise of drawing & painting and a commitment to learn are the only requirements needed to join the course. The aim of this Academy is to provide a platform from which the individual artist can develop. Courses include cast, still life, figure, portrait drawing and painting and also landscape painting. For more infomation visit their website
I am delighted to be their patron and you can listen to my speech on Youtube using the following link.
The Conservationist You can Believe In. Green Philosophy. By Patrick Allitt for Library of Law and Liberty.
The words “conservative” and “conservation” are similar; surely their meanings overlap. They do, says the English philosopher Roger Scruton, and conservatives need to think more seriously about conservation than they have hitherto. To be a conservative is to value the cultural and political traditions we have inherited from the past, to hold them in trust, and to pass them along undiminished to our descendants. To be a conservationist is to value our ecological heritage and to pass it along undiminished to our descendants. By this telling, environmentalism ought not to have a leftish slant at all.
So why does it? Scruton believes that the emotional energy of radical environmentalists today is comparable to that of communists in the twentieth century. Believing that the old capitalist world was utterly corrupt, communists wanted to sweep away all its vestiges in the name of the new. Similarly, radical environmentalists today see our technological domination of the natural world as so menacing that they want to transform it according to completely new principles.
Even moderate environmentalists, he argues, look to supra-national organizations like the European Union or the United Nations to bring about drastic changes. Others work with single-issue non-governmental organizations (NGOs) on behalf of single-issue environmental reforms. In doing so, says Scruton, they by-pass the two social groupings that are best able to accomplish change in way that assures social continuity—the local voluntary association and the nation.
Conservatives who agree that environmental problems are real and serious, including Scruton himself, see the large-scale approach as dangerous. For him, the place to start is with “oikophilia,” love of the home. Drawing on the insights of Edmund Burke, Scruton sees the “little platoon” of local society as the best place to act on our concern for the environment. We love elements of the natural world that are familiar to us from personal experience. These are the places in which our families live, and to which we are most likely to give, voluntarily, of our time and energy. He is delighted by the “adopt-a-highway” programs he has seen on visits to the USA because they bring voluntary civic associations into immediate contact with threatened environments.
By contrast, he deplores big agencies like the EPA because they displace local associations with professional rule-bound bureaucracies. They have an incentive structure unrelated to improving particular places, and they often write one-size-fits-all rules that can be perversely irrelevant or counter-productive out in the field. He cites the example of the EPA’s inability to accept the Dutch offer of pollution-abatement ships during the Deepwater Horizon emergency of 2010 because these ships could not meet the EPA’s impossibly high standard of decontaminating seawater to a purity level of 99.95 percent. Ships that could have helped remove vast quantities of crude oil from the spill zone—and had done so often in the North Sea–were excluded because of the very slightly contaminated water they would have disgorged back into the sea.
Centralized and bureaucratic responses, Scruton continues, make individuals and localities feel irrelevant and powerless, which in turn makes them progressively less eager to work voluntarily on behalf of the natural world. Bureaucracies are by nature inflexible, unable to respond quickly to new insights and experiences, and their unintended effect is to rob citizens of their sense of involvement, and the local level of its resilience. They also tend to be immune to challenge. This was particularly true in the Communist countries before 1989, whose environmental record was atrocious, and against which citizens had no recourse. Unfortunately, their record has often been little better in the West, where bureaus like the British Forestry Commission have run roughshod over centuries of local tradition in forest management.
Is the free market the solution? Scruton warns that it does not have a ready answer to all environmental questions. Some things we hold sacred beyond any question of their monetary value. Nevertheless, he is sympathetic to free-market environmentalism of the sort advocated by the American writers Terry Anderson and Donald Leal. Its basic premise is that owners have the greatest incentive to care for land that is their actual property, and are quickest to safeguard it, in appropriate ways, from external threats. He cites the success of private associations like the Anglers’ Conservation Association, which acquired lands along scenic British riverbanks and then successfully sued industrial polluters to stop them degrading water quality and killing the fish.
One role the government must play, however, is to uphold the rule of law. Without an equitable legal framework, the market can be rapacious and destructive. Scruton knows that corporations want to maximize profits and take as little responsibility as possible for the malignant environmental effects of their work. He offers high praise to the tradition of tort law in England, which has consistently taken the view that those whose enterprises cause environmental harm must take responsibility for remedying it. By contrast, he argues, American tort law has lost touch with this noble tradition. Too often, predatory American lawyers promote class-action lawsuits, targeting any organization that is able to pay and thenmaking it pay, whether or not it is responsible for the harm.
What about the claim, often heard today in environmental debates, that we have moral obligations to the future? Scruton agrees that we should take seriously our role as caretakers of a civilization and an ecology that others will inherit. This sense of obligation, and the self-restraint that ought to accompany it, are important elements of conservatism and equally of conservation. At the same time, we know much about the past and nothing about the future, so our concern for the future ought to draw heavily on the fund of actual experience we have from the past. Otherwise we will drift away into wishful thinking and utopian projections with little concern for people whose actual lives have yet to begin, and whose mentality we can scarcely imagine.
Scruton writes shrewdly on the “precautionary principle,” often invoked in environmental debates. Laudable on its face, the precautionary principle counsels us to do nothing rather than to take steps that might be environmentally harmful, just as the Hippocratic Oath enjoins doctors: “First, do no harm.” But he shows how pernicious it can be in practice. When a Danish researcher suggested that phthalates in certain plastic water bottles might be carcinogenic, the European Union invoked the precautionary principle to ban their use. Other research did not uphold the finding but the hint of a suspicion remained. In a situation like this, says Scruton, “what the Principle really says, when examined in the context of its use, is this; ‘if you think there may be a risk, then there is a risk; and if there is a risk, forbid it” (198). Here again, bureaucratic agencies making blanket decisions deny citizens the opportunity to exercise their judgment and decide for themselves what risks they are, and are not, willing to confront when the evidence is weak or ambiguous.
One of the most influential statements of an environmental dilemma is Garrett Hardin’s “Tragedy of the Commons.” First outlined in a short article in 1968, it shows that many individuals, each of them acting rationally on his own account, will use up a scarce resource, degrading the environment. A classic example is the overfishing of the oceans by too many trawlers from competing nations. Hardin, when he wrote the article, also had in mind the “commons” of reproduction, and he deplored the idea that individuals should be free to choose how many children they wanted. Collectively, he feared, they would create far too many and would overwhelm the earth’s capacity to support them. Even though Hardin was wrong about that, failing to notice the great slowing down of population growth in the advanced industrial nations, his general point still seemed persuasive.
Scruton responds to Hardin by asking the historical question: how often have “commons” actually been destroyed in this way? His answer is reassuring; very few. He gives examples from Scandinavia to Switzerland of local communities, fishermen and pastoralists, recognizing the scarcity of a vital common resource and imposing on themselves rules to preserve it. They can do so because they are familiar with the place in all its particulars, feeling not merely the economic wisdom of restraint and cooperation, but a sense of piety toward the land and its bounty. They are oikophiliacs. Scruton sees that a multicultural society with a highly mobile population will find this approach much more difficult because the many diverse parts of such a population lack a common history in the same landscape. To him, of course, multiculturalism is a negative concept.
What about the question of global warming? How serious is it, and how remediable? Scruton’s approach is sensible and level headed. He affirms that human activity is currently contributing to warming, but adds that it is only one of many sources of greenhouse gases. We should take seriously the need to diminish greenhouse gases where possible but not if the price of doing so imperils other worthwhile projects. In his view, which I share, we should take heart from the history of adaptations that humanity has made to an immense variety of climatic situations and atmospheric changes. He cites the way in which nineteenth century Britain responded to the unprecedented challenges of industrialization, and anticipates that our far more resilient society today will also show the ability to adapt.
After a wide-ranging survey of the field, including excursions back to philosophical first principles, Scruton offers a few proposals of his own. He comes down strongly in favor of reviving localism, enabling Britain’s farmers to sell the food they grow in local markets and phasing out the hidden subsidies that give all the advantages to giant supermarket chains. He favors a flat tax on carbon consumption, emphasizing that consumers, not producers, are ultimately responsible for the greenhouse gases now threatening us. And he ends by reminding readers that conservatism and conservation stand and fall together: “The greatest danger to the environment, it seems to me, comes from the growing tendency of governments to confiscate the powers and freedoms of autonomous associations, and to centralize all powers in their own hands” (400). Of course governments, especially those of the wealthy democratic nations, must play a role in response to the greatest environmental threats, but mostly by promoting oikophila rather than weakening it further.
This is a book of extraordinary richness, which repays slow reading and re-reading. Scruton has a marvelous intellectual breadth and he ranges widely over dozens of topics with equal authority, from the most abstract to the most particular. He convinced me at one point that there is a relationship between the aesthetics of table settings and the right ordering of the natural world. Families whose everyday objects have been “polished by domestic affection” (263) bespeak a sense of habitual rootedness. In a meditation on the nature of beauty, he raises the possibility that the job of art should be not to stand out but to fit in, that it should be an exercise as much of self-denial as of self-expression. What a beautiful and persuasive idea that is; one we rarely hear in an age of outsized artistic egos. It makes perfect sense in the context of his remarks on the stylistic unity of Europe’s finest cities.
Conservatives regard civilization as fragile, jeopardized by human thoughtlessness. Now it is time to take more seriously the idea that our folly can harm the natural world too. Let us recognize the profound good sense of this idea, and then consult Roger Scruton for guidance on how to be a conservative conservationist.
Roger's review on Milan Kundera's The Festival of Insignificance features in the June edition of Literary Review.
The Festival of Insignificance
By Milan Kundera
Milan Kundera writes in French nowadays, and the people he writes about are as French as the language used to describe them. But he has not lost the whimsical Czech sensibility of his earlier works. His characters are still uncertain as to why they exist or whether it was entirely fair of their author to invent them. Kundera is one of those modern writers - Beckett is another - whose protagonists are not really detachable from the words on the page. They flicker on the paper like shadows cast by the syntax. They live in dreams of their own, and their interest lies not in what they do but in what they might have done had their creator offered them a story.
Kundera has an inimitable lightness of touch; he avoids literary effect and respects the residues of meaning that accumulate in ordinary things. These features of his style succeed somehow in persuading the reader that his characters are true to the strange but harmless emptiness of the world we live in now. The Festival of Insignificance announces this theme in its title. It describes a handful of characters who coincide at a birthday party, which was to be a final birthday party, except that the host's cancer scare proved to be unfounded.
Alain, whose narrative opens the book, is obsessed with navels - the navels that young girls now expose to public view, and his own navel, which was once poked by his mother, the sole remembered gesture of affection by the woman to whom he was once linked by this very part of him. Alain's mother abandoned him when he was young, but her disembodied voice pursues him. The conversation between them occurs in the background, a banal and pointless muttering.
Ramon is an art lover, whose life of retirement leaves him with little energy either to queue for exhibitions or to set off in pursuit of the women who catch his eye. Charles and Caliban are failed actors who make a living by catering for private parties and who communicate with each other in a nonsense language that they describe as Pakistani.
Kundera steers these characters towards routine events and ordinary people, egging them on to find significance in the very insignificance of everything that happens to them. There is no story, simply a series of tableaus, carefully and economically presented, but with a view to showing that meaning is there on the page, not in some beyond for which the words are reaching. Kundera is not absent from the narrative. At one point he writes, 'The four friends I have introduced here - Alain, Ramon, Charles and Caliban - I love. In my fondness for them, I brought Charles the Khrushchev book for them all to enjoy.' The book is the Memoirs of Nikita Khrushchev, which contains stories of Stalin and his entourage.
Kundera has always been obsessed by Stalin, as is understandable for someone brought up in the Czechoslovakia of the 1960s. He uses this opportunity to relay Khrushchev's banal stories of the tyrant, and also to meditate at length on Kalinin, the insignificant member of the Politburo whose name we nevertheless know - Kaliningrad being the name bestowed on Königsberg when Stalin seized the city at the end of the war. Kalinin's very insignificance is what interests Kundera. After all, if he had been significant, wouldn the city made famous by Kant still bear Kalinin's name? Surely it would have gone the way of Stalingrad and Leningrad.
Certain themes link the episodes together. One in particular catches the reader's attention, which is the theme of the angel. Alain's obsession with navels leads him to suppose that angels must be without them, since they are never born. This gives rise to an interesting rumination on the anatomy of Eve. The vision of a slim, navel-free but beautiful body provides Alain with a symbol of chastity. And Caliban, encountering a modest Portuguese maid in the kitchen of the apartment where he is performing his duties as a caterer, is also granted a vision of angels.
A feather, floating beneath the ceiling of the room where the party is taking place, has perhaps, thinks Ramon, been dropped by a fallen angel. A sexy woman, recently bereaved, catches it on the tip of her finger. 'Heaven has sent me', she says, 'a sign that my life is to be even more glorious than before.' And in Khrushchev's fragmentary narrative the Politburo look up startled in the room where they sit to see an angel falling beyond the window.
Somehow this angel, imagined in different ways by each of the characters, summarises both the insignificance of the events surrounding them and the significance that can be found in this very insignificance. The French used to be in the habit of saying, when there is a lull in events, un ange passé. Maybe the little tableaus in Kundera's strange fiction illustrate that saying. Each episode, understated but nevertheless polished until you can see right through it to the emptiness beyond, is pure and diaphanous, like an angel. But I reached the end of the book without discovering the point of any of the characters. Which I suppose is the point.
You can read the article online here
The Festival of Insignificance
By Milan Kundera
(Translated by Linda Asher)
(Faber & Faber 115pp £14.99
Politics and society
Q&A with Marco Respinti - “The American Republican Party Italian-style” and other reflections
MR: Most of Europe is politically moving leftward but, even if unpredictably, the Conservative Party has won political elections in the UK. In Italy, a kind of Blairite new Democratic Party (formerly the Italian Communist Party) is governing, technically unelected, since months with no challenge neither opposition. Silvio Berlusconi, the man that for 20 years has set the political climate of the country, today leads a small, litigious center-right party that once was the would-be driving force for Italian change. Looking for a second chance, he knows launches the idea of establishing “an American Republican Party Italian-style”. Out of nowhere? More or less, and this is the problem. Someone takes him seriously, and is already organizing, both officially and unofficially, political actions and political meetings. But the effort seems already doomed if it will, as before, as usual, lack of substantial political culture. Will the “American Republican Party Italian-style” seek for sound inspiration? Well, Dr. Roger Scruton’s “How to be a Conservative” (London: Bloomsbury 2014) would perfectly do. What follows is a brief discussion on the subject with one of the most brilliant contemporary philosopher (and writer, teacher, composer, businessman and hunter).
MR: Do you consider the British and American two-party system as a source of political stability? Still?
RS: It is undeniable that Britain and America have been stable for longer and through more changes than any of the European countries. But maybe we should not put it down to the two-party system, but to the fact that so much of decision making takes place in committees, courts of law, advisory bodies and civic institutions. The problem now is that the new political class in both major parties has grown away from the people. Whether some other way of voting would introduce greater stability I do not know.
MR: What are the major flaws, problems, and damages that you see in countries, like Italy, were the two-party system isn’t secured yet?
RS: The major problem in Italy is surely corruption, rather than the party system. I suspect that the division of Italy between North and South would lead to a stable North, and a failing South.
MR: Which are ‒ in your opinion ‒ the major political and institutional differences (going also to the cultural side of it, if you wish) between the British and American model on one side and the Italian/European on the other?
RS: Common law versus Napoleonic judicial system; private versus public education; strong civil society versus top-down administration; strong charitable giving versus dependence on the state.
MR: How do you explain the recent victory of the Tories in the UK (and the huge loss of UKIP) in spite of the electoral uncertainty of the eve and their poor record for true blue conservatives?
RS: The explanation lies partly in the recognition that a strong and committed government is after all better than votes wasted on small parties that are not going to achieve representation in Parliament. True blue Tories also have a tendency to vote for the Party, even when they disagree with it.
<< Start < Prev 1 2 3 4 5 Next > End >>
Page 1 of 5
Roger's review on Milan Kundera's The Festival of Insignificance features in the June edition of Literary Review.
The Festival of InsignificanceBy Milan Kundera
Milan Kundera writes in French nowadays, and the people he...Read more
Listen back to Roger with Richard Reinsch.
Roger has recently discussed with Richard Reinsch, of Liberty Law Talk, his newest novel The Disappeared. Listen to the Podcast here. Read more
The Disappeared is launched on 26th March 2015 by Bloomsbury Reader. It is a story of our times, of kidnap and rescue, of abuse and healing. The first magazine...Read more
What does it mean to be a conservative in an age so sceptical of conservatism? How can we live in the presence of our 'canonized forefathers' at a time when...Read more
The Soul of the World is a defence of the sacred against today's fashionable forms of atheism. Our personal relationships, moral intuitions, and aesthetic judgments hint at a transcendent dimension...Read more
Published March 2014 by Beaufort Books
A novel set in the twilight years of the Czechoslovak communist regime, this novel describes a doomed love affair between two young people trapped in...Read more
For most people in England today, the church is simply the empty building at the end of the road, visited for the first time, if at all, when dead. It...Read more
Atlantic Books (January 2012)
The environment has long been the undisputed territory of the political Left, which has seen the principal threats to the earth as issuing from international capitalism,...Read more
The Uses of Pessimism and the Danger of False Hope
Atlantic Books (2010)
The argument of this book proposes that the tragedies and disasters of the history of the European continent...Read more
Roger Scruton explores this timeless concept, asking what makes an object--either in art, in nature, or the human form--beautiful. This compact volume is filled with insight. Can there be...Read more
Philosophy and Interpretation
Continuum (2009)ISBN: 9781847065063
Roger Scruton first addressed this topic in his celebrated book The Aesthetics of Music (OUP) and in this new book he applies the theory to...Read more
The Palgrave Macmillan Dictionary of Political Thought
Macmillan Publishers Ltd (2007)ISBN-10: 1403989524 , ISBN-13: 978-1403989529
Roger Scruton's Dictionary of Political Thought has been widely acclaimed as a profound and incisive guide to...Read more
News from Somewhere: On Settling
Continuum (2004)ISBN: 9780826476289 192 pages, paperback
For a number of years Roger Scruton has contributed a weekly article to the Financial Times on country matters. Always beautifully...Read more
A Political Philosophy
Arguments for Conservatism
Continuum (2006)ISBN-10: 0826496156, ISBN-13: 978-0826496157
What principles should govern our relations to the nation-state, to the environment, to other species, to other cultures and to other ways...Read more
England: An Elegy
Continuum (2001) ISBN: 9780826480750288 Pages, paperback
In this poignant and personal tribute Roger Scruton gives an account of England which is both an illuminating analysis of its institutions and...Read more
Faith and Feeling in a World Besieged
Encounter Books (2008)Hardcover 136 pages ISBN: 1594031940
What is culture? Why should we preserve it, and how? In this book, the renowned philosopher Roger...Read more
Sex and the Sacred in Wagner's Tristan and Isolde
OUP (2004)246 pages, 978-0-19-516691-0 | Hardback
A tale of forbidden love and inevitable death, the medieval legend of Tristan and Isolde recounts...Read more
The Classical Vernacular
Architectural Principles in an Age of Nihilism
Carcanet Press (1995)ISBN-10: 1 857540 54 9, ISBN-13: 978 1 857540 54 3, 1st Format: Hardback, 176pp
Roger Scruton is never less than...Read more
Animal Rights and Wrongs
Continuum (1996, 1998, 3rd ed 2000)ISBN: 9780826494047
A revised and improved edition of a book in continuing demand.
Do animals have rights? If not, do we have duties towards...Read more
An Intelligent Person's Guide to Philosophy
Penguin Books (1996)ISBN-10: 0140275169, ISBN-13: 978-0140275162. Paperback: 176 pages
"Philosophy's the 'love of wisdom', can be approached in two ways: by doing it, or by studying...Read more
An Intelligent Person's Guide to Modern Culture
St. Augustine’s Press (1998. new ed. 2000)ISBN: 978-1-890318-47-5, 186 pages
Received by the British press with equal acclaim and indignation, this book sets out to...Read more
The Aesthetics of Architecture
PUP (1980)ISBN13: 978-0-691-00322-1
Scruton takes his readers on a journey through aesthetic theory and tries in every sense to apply them directly to architecture. By using theories from...Read more
Aesthetics of Music
OUP (1999)ISBN13: 9780198167273 ISBN10: 019816727X Paperback, 552 pages
What is music, what is its value, and what does it mean? In this stimulating volume, Roger Scruton offers a comprehensive...Read more
The Great Philosophers
Routledge (1999)SBN-13: 9780415923903ISBN: 0415923905
Philosophy is one of the most intimidating and difficult of disciplines, as any of its students can attest. This book is an important entry in...Read more
A Short History of Modern Philosophy
Routledge (1982, 1995, 3rd ed, 2001)Isbn10: 0415130352
In this classic introductory work, Scruton takes us on us on a fascinating tour of the subject, from founding...Read more
Continuum (1986, 2006)ISBN: 9780826480385, 448 Pages, paperback
When John desires Mary or Mary desires John, what does either of them want? What is meant by innocence, passion, love and arousal,...Read more
The Politics of Culture and Other Essays
St. Augustine's Press (1981)245 pages, ISBN-10: 1890318612, ISBN-13: 978-1890318611
Brings together Scruton's best essays from many sources, arranging them thematically. The book has four sections:...Read more
The Aesthetic Understanding
St. Augustine's Press (1983, new ed. 1997)ISBN: 978-1-890318-02-4
Brings together essays on the philosophy of art in which a philosophical theory of aesthetic judgment is tested and developed through...Read more
Philosopher on Dover Beach
St. Augustine's Press (1989)350 pages, ISBN: 978-1-890318-60-4
In this collection of previously published essays, Scruton casts his philosophically conservative mind over a variety of subjects from Hegel to...Read more
Perictione in Colophon
Reflections on the Aesthetic
Way of Life
St. Augustine's Press (2000)263 pages, ISBN: 978-1-890318-59-8
This, the sequel to the same author's much-acclaimed Xanthippic Dialogues, is a multi-faceted commentary on the...Read more
Yellow Jersey Press (1998)173 pages, ISBN: 978-1-58731-600-5
Modern people are as given to loving, fearing, fleeing, and pursuing other species as were their hunter-gatherer forebears. And in fox hunting, they...Read more
An introduction and survey
Penguin Books, (1994)Paperback | 624 pages | ISBN 9780140249071
Philosopher Roger Scruton offers a wide-ranging perspective on philosophy, from logic to aesthetics, written in a lively and...Read more
The Meaning of Conservatism
St. Augustine's Press (1980, 1984, 3rd ed. 2000)220 pages, ISBN: 978-1-890318-40-6
This is a major contribution to political thought from conservatism's greatest contemporary proponent. Originally published in Britain...Read more
A Very Short Introduction
OUP (1993, new ed. 2001)160 pages |978-0-19-280199-9 | Paperback
Kant is arguably the most influential modern philosopher, but also one of the most difficult. Roger Scruton tackles his...Read more
I Drink Therefore I am
Continuum (2009)ISBN-10: 1441170677, ISBN-13: 978-1441170675
The ancients had a solution to the alcohol problem, which was to wrap the drink in religious rituals, to treat it...Read more
Continuum (2006)ISBN: 9780826480330 256 Pages, paperback
Roger Scruton is Britain's best known intellectual dissident, who has defended English traditions and English identity against an official culture of denigration. Although his...Read more
Carcanet Press (1981)ISBN-10: 0 856353 76 0
ISBN-13: 978 0 856353 76 5Edition:1st
Buy from AmazonRead more
A Very Short Introduction
OUP (2002)144 pages, 978-0-19-280316-0
Benedict de Spinoza (1632-77) was at once the father of the Enlightenment and the last sad guardian of the medieval world. In his brilliant...Read more
A Land Held Hostage: Lebanon and the West
Published by The Claridge Press, London (1987)
In this book, published in 1987 during the course of Lebanon's civil wars, Roger Scruton...Read more